pinterest tag

Coffee For French Press: 5 Popular Amazon Picks To Buy Now

tattooed arm pouring coffee from stainless french press into white ceramic mug on wooden stool, coffee for french press

Heads up: This content is reader-supported, meaning we may earn a small commission if you click on some of our links.

Enjoying a rich and heady cup of French press coffee is an epic way to start any day. But selecting coffee for French press brewing can be tricky.

This is because French press coffee is bold by nature, leaving many scratching their heads when choosing between dark roast and light roast, and everything in between. Especially when scrolling through seemingly endless options on Amazon.

That’s where we come in. We scoured Amazon, tested more coffee brands than we can count, and found five picks that are great coffee for French press and brands you can feel good about supporting.

So let’s get to it.

Best Coffee for French Press

A great cup of coffee starts with the right coffee bean. Obviously, we like to think that our coffee beans make an exceptional choice for French press brewing, but we understand that convenience and instant gratification are paramount these days. That’s why we’ve scoured Amazon to find the best coffee for French press brewing.

When purchasing French press coffee beans, paying attention to the roast level, origin, and freshness is crucial. The roast level determines the flavor and aroma of the coffee, with darker roasts having a bolder and more intense flavor.

The origin of the coffee can also affect its taste, with different regions producing distinct flavors. Lastly, freshness is key to a flavorful cup of coffee, so it’s best to purchase whole-bean coffee and grind it just before brewing.

We also believe supporting organic farming efforts is extremely important, so we only tested organic varieties for this roundup.

Whether you’re a fan of bold roasts or prefer something a bit milder, we’ve got you covered. So get ready to brew up a delicious cup of French press coffee with our top picks for the best coffee for French press.

Subtle Earth Organic Coffee

Subtle Earth Organic Coffee

If you’re looking for a high-quality, low-acid coffee for French press, we recommend Subtle Earth Organic Coffee from Cafe Don Pablo.

Pros

  • The beans are sourced from Honduras, giving the coffee a full-bodied, deep, rich, chocolatey flavor with a clean finish and low acidity.
  • The coffee has aromatic notes of smooth milk chocolate with hints of honey, caramel, and cocoa.
  • The beans are artisan-roasted in small batches just prior to shipping to ensure peak flavor and optimal freshness.

Cons

  • The price has increased significantly recently, making it less affordable for some coffee lovers.
  • Some customers have received coffee bags past their best-before date, resulting in a less-than-ideal flavor profile.
  • The coffee is only available in whole-bean form, which may not be ideal for those who prefer pre-ground coffee. (although we don’t recommend buying pre-ground coffee anyway)

We love Subtle Earth Organic Coffee’s rich, chocolatey flavor and low acidity. It’s perfect for French press brewing, as it always produces a full-bodied, delicious cup of coffee. The beans are expertly roasted in small batches, ensuring optimal freshness and flavor.

While the price has gone up in recent years, we still think it’s worth the investment for coffee lovers who want a high-quality, organic product from a family-owned, sustainably-minded company. Just be sure to check the best-before date on your bag to ensure optimal freshness.

These guys are confident you’ll love their coffee, but if you don’t, they’ll refund your purchase, no questions asked. That’s our kind of guarantee.

San Francisco Bay Whole Bean Coffee – Organic Rainforest Blend

San Francisco Bay Whole Bean Coffee - Organic Rainforest Blend

San Francisco Bay’s Organic Rainforest Blend is a great choice if you are looking for a tasty and sustainable coffee for French press brewing.

Pros

  • Smooth and balanced flavor, also great for espresso
  • Sustainably and eco-farmed coffee
  • Satisfaction Guarantee

Cons

  • May be too strong for some coffee drinkers
  • Not the most nuanced coffee
  • Beans can be a bit oily despite the medium-dark roast category

We were surprised that we enjoyed this coffee so much. We’re fans of the smooth and balanced flavor it produced in the French press and espresso. The beans are grown in Central America, hand-picked, and grown at high altitudes, resulting in high-quality coffee.

One of the best things about San Francisco Bay Coffee is that they are sustainable and eco-farmed. They offer a wide selection of sustainably grown, sourced, and packaged coffee at a very reasonable price point. We appreciate that they are a family-owned company with a rich tradition.

If you are unsatisfied with your purchase, San Francisco Bay Coffee offers a satisfaction guarantee. They stand behind their products and are committed to providing high-quality, delicious coffee at a great value; this blend is no exception.

While this coffee is smooth and goes down easy, it lacked some of the nuances we found in others on this list. But it is straightforward and easy to drink, with a clean finish, so it’s a great option for many.

Mayorga Medium Roast Whole Bean Coffee

Mayorga Medium Roast Whole Bean Coffee

We are big fans of Mayorga Café Cubano Dark Roast for espresso, so it’s no surprise that we also love the Mayorga Mayan Blend Coffee for French press. This organic coffee blend from Mexico, Honduras, and Guatemala has a unique signature flavor profile with hints of chocolate and floral undertones, making it a crowd favorite.

Pros

  • Craft-roasted in small batches by the Roastmaster for a distinct flavor
  • 100% Arabica coffee is always shade-grown and direct-traded from Latino farmers
  • Always organic and sustainably sourced

Cons

  • It is listed as a medium roast but is more of a medium-dark roast
  • May not be suitable for those who prefer light-roast coffee
  • Some customers have received expired bags of coffee

We love how Mayorga’s signature slow-roasting process gives their coffee a silky-smooth finish. The beans are shade-grown and roasted in small batches, ensuring the highest quality. We appreciate how the company is invested in sustainability at all levels, from the environment to the farmers.

If you’re a fan of supporting Latino-owned companies that partner with farmers, Mayorga is the perfect choice for you. We recommend trying out this Mayan Blend coffee roast for a smooth and flavorful cup of coffee in your French press. It’s also as tasty as espresso.

Java Planet Low Acid Coffee

Java Planet Low Acid Coffee

If you are looking for an organic and low-acid coffee that’s as delicious as it is sustainable, then Java Planet Columbia Organic might be the perfect choice for you.

Pros

  • Smooth finish with beautiful fruit undertones
  • Organic and Rainforest Alliance Certified
  • ‘Roasted On’ date included on every bag = guaranteed freshness

Cons

  • Only available in whole bean (grind coffee just before brewing)
  • The dark roast may not be suitable for those who prefer lighter roasts.
  • Price may be higher than other coffee brands.
fellow opus grinder
The Fellow Opus Grinder

We were impressed with the quality and flavor of this organic Columbian coffee. It has a round mouthfeel and full bold and rich flavor, with beautiful fruit tones that make it an ideal coffee for French press.

It is also organic and Rainforest Alliance Certified, meaning you can enjoy your coffee with peace of mind knowing that you support fair pricing, workers’ rights, and protecting wildlife and the environment.

One of the best things about Java Planet Columbia Organic is that it is free from pesticides and mold. Java Planet independently tests all coffee for mycotoxins, ensuring you only absorb beneficial antioxidants naturally found in coffee grown at high altitudes. This makes it a great choice for health-conscious people looking for a healthier alternative to regular coffee.

Cameron’s Organic Scandinavian Blend Whole Bean Coffee

Cameron's Coffee Organic Scandinavian Blend Whole Bean Coffee

We highly recommend Cameron’s Organic Scandinavian Blend Coffee to French press lovers who want to enjoy a rich, velvety smooth cup of coffee.

Pros

  • The medium-dark roast is mild, balanced, and rich, with a smooth finish that is perfect for French press brewing.
  • The 4-pound bag of whole-bean coffee is an excellent value for the price, and the coffee is 100% premium Arabica beans.
  • Cameron’s Coffee is committed to making every day brighter by roasting in small batches and reducing water consumption. They care about their coffee, farmers, and the environment.

Cons

  • The packaging may vary, and the coffee will ship in a plain white bag with a black label (bulk coffee).
  • The larger bulk bags (4 lbs) are more difficult to store properly.
  • The coffee is on the darker side of medium, so it may not be suitable for those who prefer a lighter roast.
Airscape vacuum coffee canister in matte black
Airscape Stainless Steel Coffee Canister

Cameron’s Coffee Organic Scandinavian Blend is a medium-dark roast that is mild but exceptionally balanced, with a smooth finish. We love this coffee for French press, and we think you will too. The 4-pound bag of whole-bean coffee is an excellent value for the price, and the coffee is organic and sustainably produced.

Cameron’s Coffee is committed to making every day brighter by roasting in small batches and reducing water consumption. They care about their coffee, farmers, and the environment.

If you’re looking for a high-quality coffee for French press brewing, Cameron’s Coffee Organic Scandinavian Blend is an excellent choice.

fellow clara french press with walnut handle
Get the Fellow Clara French Press

French Press Buying Guide

So, now you’ve got the best coffee for French press but no French press coffee maker to brew it in? We got you.

With so many French presses on the market today, choosing the best one for you can be overwhelming. Here are some things to consider when buying a French press:

Size Matters

The first thing to consider is the size of the French press. How much coffee do you want to make at once? If you’re the only coffee drinker in your household, a small 1-2 cup press might be perfect for you.

But if you are brewing coffee for a family or like to entertain guests, you might want to go for a larger 8-12 cup press. Remember that the larger the press, the more coarse ground coffee you’ll need to use.

Material

French presses can be made from different materials like glass, stainless steel, or ceramic. Each material has its pros and cons.

Glass is visually appealing, easy to clean but fragile, and can break easily. Stainless steel is durable and can keep your coffee hot for longer, but it may impart a metallic taste to the coffee.

A ceramic French press is an excellent option for heat retention and optimal flavor, but these presses are harder to find and expensive.

french press filter and lid laying on its side on granite counter

Filter

The filter is one of the most essential elements of the French press. It is attached to the plunger and separates the coffee grounds from the hot water.

There are two types of filters: metal and nylon mesh. Metal filters are more durable and can last for years, but they can let some sediment through, which can affect the taste of your coffee. They require a coarse grind size to work properly.

Nylon filters are finer and produce a cleaner cup of coffee, but they are more difficult to clean and must be replaced more frequently. Mesh filters allow you to experiment with different grind sizes as they will not let as much sediment through.

Additional Features

Some French presses include additional features, such as double-walled insulation, a built-in timer, or a travel mug. These features can improve your coffee experience but also have a higher price tag. Consider if these features are important to you before making a purchase.

So, what’s our favorite French press? We love the Fellow Clara French press. It has the best heat retention we’ve found, looks beautiful on your kitchen counter (like all of the Fellow products), and is a snap to clean. It produces some of the best French press coffee we’ve had.

That’s it for our buying guide. We hope these tips help you choose the best coffee for French press (and the best French press) for you. Happy brewing!

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Heather Calatrello

Heather Calatrello owner of ShedLight Coffee Roasters